How to Identify a Good Accident Attorney You can tell if they are a reputable accident attorney by their track record of success in car accident cases. How they answer difficult questions is a good indication of their expertise. They should be able manage your case effectively. Choose an attorney firm that has enough staff to assist with medical records requests and other administrative tasks. 1. Experience A skilled car accident lawyer will have enough experience to be familiar with all the ins and outs of personal injury laws. They will have a comprehensive understanding of the complicated aspects of your case and be able to use this knowledge to negotiate an equitable settlement. They should be able to address your questions and explain the legal procedure in a manner that's easy to comprehend. During your initial meeting, you will want to find out how much experience your potential lawyer has with car accident cases.